Low and Moderate Income Housing
Development Task Force
Monday, April 27, 2026 - 11:00 am
Ken Hughes - Chairman
Chairman Hughes called this task force to
order at 11:00 am with the following in attendance: Clayton Barber, Timothy
Follos, Ken Hughes, Tracie McGill, Clayton Menser, Terri Morse (11:10), James
O’Bryan, Tim Pierce, Davina Thurston, and Carol Calabrese. Angie Allen, Matt
Brassard, Matt Stanley, Joe Pete Wilson, Adam DeSantis, Dan Kelleher, and
Nicole Justice-Green were excused. Alan Jones and Caitlyn Wargo were absent.
Also present: - Dina Garvey, and Renee
Bruno
HUGHES: Okay, good morning, everybody.
We’ll get the Housing Task Force underway. Thank you very much for being here.
I apologize that we had a double booking last month and so we weren’t able to
attend that event. So, I just moved everything from the March meeting to this
morning.
There’s a couple of follow-up items. I
kind of reorganized the agenda a little bit. There’s a couple of follow up
items that we were going to take a look at today from Mr. Tansey and myself and
then agenda item #3 is going to start taking a look at, we’re not to talk about
every single one of those, but start talking a look at how, we as a committee,
what to support the process moving forward and I think something that Mike said
in the last meeting is really beneficial to what we’re looking at here, is we
have 18 different towns, 18 different cultures and ideas and desires and so for
example for the County to pass a moratorium that affects all 18 towns may not
be in the best interest of every single town. We have different needs and wants
in each town and so I kind of take that same perspective here, as this Task
Force should be supporting the individual needs of the Towns and that we’re not
looking to pass any type of major County legislation that’s going to force a
Town to do something. I’m not interested in seeing us doing that, but if
there’s a Town that does have something and we can use that intelligence to
support a Town that doesn’t have something but wants that something that this
Task Force can maybe support that process.
So, I just wanted to, so we’ll go back
to 2a, the March 5 Workforce Housing Forum from the ADK Community Foundation.
There were a couple of presenters in the room, I don’t think any of them were
here. I was hoping Nicole Justice-Green was a presenter, so was I think Dan
Kelleher and ROOST, they were presenters, but they’re not here today. I think
they’re down in Albany. So, my quick take away, I think some of you were in the
room. My quick take away from that was that it was wonderful that they received
the money from New York State. It was more about middle income housing; this is
the Low and Moderate Income Housing Task Force. So, it’s awesome that middle
income opportunities are existing and there’s funding there for those
opportunities, however it is a little outside of our lane in terms of what our
mission is and what we’re looking to do, but it was great to see that there is
some action and some energy and resources that are being put into that
revolving loan fund to support middle income housing in our counties. I don’t
know if anybody else was there that wants to speak about that quickly,
beautiful venue in Schroon Lake. It was my first time there, it was great.
Anybody want to speak to this.
THURSTON: I was there, actually sat with
Ken.
HUGHES: Yeah
THURSTON: It was a wonderful program,
Nicole, of course, was very eloquent in her speech, so it was really nice to
see her and Adam from ROOST, you know talking about Essex County in particular.
HUGHES: Yeah
THURSTON: So, certainly affordable
housing is an issue everywhere in our County and you know just having that many
people in the room was really great.
HUGHES: It was a packed house.
THURSTON: It was.
HUGHES: Yup, thank you for those
comments. Anybody else wish to comment who was there?
Okay, let’s move on now to 2b. There was
a conversation about, at our last meeting in February, definitions of blighted
properties, unsafe structures and nuisance properties. Before I turn the mic
over to Mr. Tansey, I just want to have you take a look at, I think it’s page 2
of the document, the packet that I gave you. I went to New York State
Department of State, to their local law area, their local law database and I
did a search for every single town, whether they had a blighted property law,
an unsafe structure law or a nuisance property law. So, you can see here that,
again, there’s a percentage of error here on my part, but from what I found,
there was no local laws at the Department of State that stated that there was a
Blighted Property Law. I did find several towns, and you see the dates there
that were enacted for Unsafe Structure Laws. Nobody had a nuisance property law
except for St. Armand. Several towns did have a junk storage local law, and I
marked that with a hashtag next to that nuisance property. So, I assumed that
potentially nuisance could also be identified as junk storage law and I put
those dates down as well. Again, there’s a percentage of errors here, but when
it comes to unsafe structure there is at least 7 of our towns that don’t have
that and so it’s possible that this committee might recommend supporting those
towns having an unsafe structure law. That might be a directive of this
committee, I don’t know, to provide just for support to them so that we can
deal with blighted properties or again, unsafe structure properties.
So, I want to turn it over to Mr. Tansey
and Mr. Manning.
MANNING: Ken, I think there are blighted
property local laws on the DOS website. They provide for a blighted property
registration system.
HUGHES: Okay
MANNING: And there’s a distinction between;
there is a subtle distinction between blighted properties and unsafe building.
So, there are, I did some, I gave it to Bill, but I pulled 4,5,6 blighted
property local laws.
HUGHES: In Essex County?
MANNING: Not in Essex County, throughout
the whole State.
HUGHES: Oh, I only looked at Essex
County.
MANNING: Okay
HUGHES: I only looked at Essex County.
MANNING: That makes sense.
PIERCE: I am not on this Task Force, but
Lewis, you talk about nuisance property, we do have a junk property law on the
books.
HUGHES: Okay, that’s my margin of error
right there. I did a key word search for those words.
O’BRYAN: We also have one.
MANNING: I would guess that you all have
one. These are laws that went out in the 80s.
PIERCE: This was back in 1978.
HUGHES: That’s a quick, fun point. I
think the database on DOS doesn’t go back any further than 1998.
MANNING: If it’s 78, you may want to
update it.
HUGHES: Yeah, 1998 I think is the
earliest that it exists on the New York State website, so I would have been
privy to that information.
So, the margin of error at least
provides for just a set of databases to show that there maybe are some
imperfections or maybe opportunities to update.
MANNING: I apologize.
HUGHES: That’s okay, that’s why we’re
having this conversation to update our local laws to potentially reflect more
modern times.
BARBER: Ken, the Town of Chesterfield
does have an unsafe structure law.
HUGHES: Pre-1998?
BARBER: That I couldn’t tell you on what
date that was actually enacted.
HUGHES: This is that opportunity, if you
want to get me that information that would be great. If you have a date then I
could update this document just so we have it just for our edification, that
would be fine.
So, we were unclear about what the
definitions are. We were looking for some legal information about this. So, I
will turn it over to Mr. Tansey who’s done some awesome work.
TANSEY: Thank you, I put together a
small sheet. I described Unsafe Building and Blight Law just in a quick
overview. Those would be the two that I would think were pertinent and nuisance
in the last one. I think when we think of unsafe laws, unsafe building laws
we’re thinking of danger, something that is unsafe that is going to cause
hurt/harm. Blight laws deal with decline, so we’re thinking of declining
property values, declining tax income and nuisance, nuisance we’re thinking
illegal. You’re thinking illegal businesses, excessive noise, prostitution,
gambling, drugs and when you consider what problem you want to address you also
have to consider you’re going to enforce this. Just based on those words I used;
unsafe building you’re going to need a building inspector. Somebody that can
determine the building has and is not built correctly and safety. For blight,
you’re going to need code enforcement or a health department. Somebody who can
get in there and see that it is in fact unhealthy or not up to code. Nuisance,
you’re going to need a police department, someone who can go out there and
investigate a drug scene or a drug house, investigate prostitution, investigate
gambling. If you were to do nuisance they way a lot of the nuisance laws are
put into effect is there are point values. So, if they go out there and find a
gambling house, they’ll assign two points. If they go out there and find drugs,
they’ll assign 10 points and if a particular house premise gets 12 points in a
year or 12 points in 2 months then you as a town board can institute a hearing,
perhaps put on a fine, evict tenants and go down those paths and that would be
a nuisance.
Unsafe building; I have said this
already. These deal with the structural integrity of the building. We’re going
to focus on the hazardous, fire risks. Especially houses that are burned out or
houses that have suffered a lot of rot and the main structure beams are going
to collapse. We want to have a system in place where the building inspector can
get out there and see if the people is in fact unsafe. There is a hearing
mechanism, some kind of notice to the town board to have a hearing, let the
owner have a chance to fight, out forward a defense and then the Town Board can
institute some kind of a fine as it so choses.
Blight; in a broad sense is used to
describe a neighborhood. So, we’re looking at one house that may start to
decline, because it’s maintained; tall grass, broken windows and then suddenly
your neighbors are leaving garbage out, abandoning cars and then now we have 6
houses in the neighborhood with abandoned cars and garbage. So, it affects the
entire neighborhood. So, any kind of blight law that is going to have any kind
of affect at the town board level has to be focused on an individual property
and a lot of times blight is first addressed in the codes. The zoning of the
town where you would say that your grass has to be maintained, you can’t store
abandoned vehicles in your front yard, you can’t have a camper in your front
yard, garbage has to be picked up once a week, you can’t leave garbage out in
front of the house and that would be the health department then going out to
see that that is not happening or being enforced and again, blight law can
establish a procedure for notice to the town board. The town board can have a
hearing and then impose some kind of a fine.
Unsafe Buildings Laws; you tend to see
things like the town board not liking the fact that the owner has done nothing
to maintain it. They determine the building should be demolished and then we
demolish it. In Blight Laws; you tend to see things like you’re not picking up
your garbage; you have broken windows. We’re going to give you 30-days to fix,
we have a program in town, we have loans available in town for you to come in
and get money to fix the broken windows. We have a program to fix the garbage.
We can get someone out there to mow the lawn, and we will help to pay for it. Over
or not maintaining the blight after it has been picked up on that particular
piece of property, we can put that property on a blighted list, a blighted
property list and we can add $2,500, $3,500 to the tax bill on that property in
a year.
So, I started by saying that you’ve got
to think about who you have to enforce it, building inspector, code
enforcement, health department, police department. When it comes time to
imposing a fine, to assess on the taxes, to demolish a building, now you’ve got
to think about how you’re going to pay for it. It is very simple to say that
we’re going to put a $2,500 tax assessment here, but then you’re going to
foreclose on that property and that $2,500 has to come from somewhere. It
either comes from your town coffers, county coffers, grant money, land bank
money so it is part of the consideration and when you look at an unsafe
building that could be $50,000 to demolish. Again, $50,000 has to come
somewhere, the County, town or you have to talk to the Land Bank ahead of time
for grant money. And then Blight Laws, it’s easy to say, you pay an extra
$2,500 but then to collect the $2,500 becomes an issue and then you have a
property that has to be foreclosed on. So, these are all sorts of
considerations that you have to keep in mind. Each one has a specific purpose.
It’s very conceivable to draw a draft, draw up a law that covers all three
areas; unsafe, blighted properties and then nuisance properties.
That’s a quick overview. I know the list
that Mr. Hughes gave a lot of towns have already addressed this. If you want to
refocus it and you’re not on that list for a law, please give me a call and if
you want to dive deep into the specific issues and the factors that you’re
considering and the best path forward. Any questions, concerns?
FOLLOS: Is there a reason why do think
no towns in Essex County have adopted a Blighted Property Law and is there town
that has a blighted property law that you would consider a good model or
template for one of our towns?
TANSEY: I don’t know why no town in
Essex County has not adopted. I can find you a good example, like Mr. Manning
said, there’s several towns out there. You can pull 8 or so Blighted Property
Laws throughout New York and pull parts that are really, really nice. So, there’s
not going to be one that you’re going to love, there’s going to be parts in 2-3
that you’re going to like. So, I can do that.
FOLLOS: Okay, we do get a lot of
complaints about trash in people’s yards. There’s one spot in particular that
has a dumpster that has been a problem for years. So, I think that might be
something that we would want to think about.
TANSEY: Yeah, and I think some towns
pick up a lot of the blight issues in their zoning codes.
MANNING: I just want to add to that,
trash, section 64 of the town law, allows you, there’s a little process there
for you to enforce trash enforcement and weeds and stuff like that and Bill did
a very good job in explaining the difference between blight and unsafe
buildings. Nuisances are a whole other animal; I wouldn’t touch them with a 10’
pole unless you want to get involved in making lots of laws with different
nuisances. There is also common law and there is nuisance that is used often on
the books, but that’s usually used by property owner versus property owner.
I can kind of answer the reason why none
of the Towns in Essex County have a Blighted Property Law or Blighted Property
Registry. Clayton has asked me on many occasions, I have a whole file on it,
and I gave Bill some of the stuff. My resistance was that and this is a
difficult situation, and I represent the County and I also represent you guys,
but when I have an issue that involves a bit of a conflict between the County
and the Town, it’s difficult for me to walk that tight rope. The Blighted
Property Local Laws and also the Unsafe Building Laws have a component that
allows, that you go do this and all charges are then put on the tax warrant and
the County has to pay for the tax warrant, and those charges can run the gamut
from tearing down a building, which gets very expensive to enforcing your
Blight Property Local Law. A lot of Blighted Property Local Laws have yearly
filings if your house or property is determined to be blighted then you can be,
you will assess you a registration fee of $1,500 up to $3,500. Those things can
accumulate into a lot of money, they get put on the tax rolls and then we, the County,
has to make good on the warrant. Whether the County gets that money back in
foreclosure is questionable. So, Clayton has asked me on many occasions, and I
have never did it because I was kind of torn between my allegiance to the
County. On those blighted property local laws that I have seen, they have
allowed that to be placed on tax rolls. I am not sure whether that’s an issue
that should be explored, I am not sure whether that is correct. Somebody lifted
that off of unsafe building or under Section 64 of the Town Law. You can assess
something like that generally on the tax rolls without it being in statute
would be my opinion. Some maybe that’s in some statute somewhere in blighted
properties, I have never seen it. I have never delved into it. So, that may not
even be legal. So, that’s the reason that no one here has one. It would be easy
for everyone here to have one if you want one. Bill will just grab some of
those laws, cobble it together, come up with what he thinks is best and, away
you go. But my resistance it doing it was because everything seemed to be put
on the County’s back for the warrant and I get it. So, if that’s okay with the
County, if you guys as the County decide.
MASCARENAS: It’s not.
MANNING: I know, Mike and I talk about
this a lot.
MASCARENAS: I’ve got 6 million reasons
why it’s not okay.
MANNING: I agree, I mean those things
start to pile up.
MASCARENAS: Yeah, they do.
MANNING: Thankfully you guys are not
tearing down tons of, we have what’s her face, Nicole Justice-Green, sorry
about that, no disrespect, I just couldn’t think of her name. She’s tearing
down stuff, she’s doing great, she’s getting money for you guys and that’s
great. But, if that runs dry and then all of sudden you decide, let’s all do
this and stick it on the tax rolls. Then that would be very expensive to the
County. It could get up there.
And then one other thing on blighted
properties, if I call, vacancy can be considered blight. So, if a property is
vacant for like a couple of years under some of those blighted property laws,
they get no assist and even though they’re vacant, they may be boarded up. If
they’re boarded up, they’re going to comply with your unsafe buildings law,
because they’re no danger. They may be fixed, they may be boarded, but they can
still be blighted if they’re vacant. So, that is my two cents, and thank you,
Bill. That was a great thing.
BARBER: So, I just want to, I have been
here 6 years, I have tried the unsafe building law there are just so many
things, loopholes. I had a person, specifically downtown, with his buildings
falling apart and these are attached building where a lot of my businesses are
downtown. Tried the unsafe building law, had him come in, first of all trying
to get him to even accept, we sent certified letters, contacted him several
times, I had my code officer contact him. He was returning calls in the
beginning and then quit taking calls, finally get done and then the guys goes
into bankruptcy, and I am notified, he’s in bankruptcy, got to stop, can’t do
anything while he’s in bankruptcy, got to wait until you’re out. I had that
conversation, Mike Diskin mentioned to Dan. So, the unsafe building law, to me
you might just as well left it that I don’t have one because trying to enforce
it is totally ridiculous as far as I am concerned and then getting your court to
apply.
HUGHES: That’s it.
BARBER: Getting your judges to get them
there in court and stuff and then when they get there then they give them so
much time. Blight laws, just from me saying, as soon as I get a law I want to
be the first one to adopt it because just by my Board talking about it and
every meeting, I have had a couple of places that have cleaned up their
property because I mentioned to them, they’re going to get a $2,500 yearly
fine. These same people wait their 3 years before they pay their taxes and then
they pay their taxes because they’re not that much and it’s worth keeping the
property and I think if you add the extra $2,500, this person downtown,
commercials up to $5,000, that’s the figure that you threw out that time and
he’s one of them that will go 2 year, 3 years before he pays his taxes. If he
had a $5,000 fine, he’s either not going to pay his taxes at the end of the 3
years or he doesn’t do nothing and I got other people complaining. Why should
they live, when you’re sitting there doing a revalu on properties and they come
to you, come to your Town Board and say, I’m living next to a dump and you guys
don’t do nothing about it. How is my land coming up in value when I have been
living next to this dump? I think blight property law with that fine yearly, I
think it will make people move on the subject, just like that extra thing. Like
you say, what people to do something, hit them in the pocket. They either do or
they get.
MANNING: Clayton, too, I just want to,
our, we’re back on every year’s foreclosure timeline, because Covid messed
everything up. That’s why it was a 3-year one and that’s a consideration, too,
and then you know, get back to what the County has to make good on the warrant
would be less, because you wouldn’t have 3-4 years built up, $2,500. Some might
just be $2,500 if the County eats it. I really do think the County needs to
make a decision on all these things. We kind of made a quasi-decision on taxes,
back taxes and all that, but then you’ve got unsafe building section 64 and blighted
property fines that get put back on the warrant and what do you want to do with
them.
THURSTON: So, I just had a couple of
comments. So, most of us I think or probably all of here have formally adopted
New York State Uniformed Fire Protection and Building Code, that does have
property maintenance codes in there that certainly your Code Enforcement
Officer can do a code violation on any property for property maintenance
regardless of whether you have a blight property. I absolutely agree with Clayton,
you know, if it goes in front of a Judge, we have to have our judges actually
follow through. So, you know, in your Town, if you have a Judge that maybe is
cousins or something with whoever this person is, send it to the next Town over
and eliminate that problem.
As far as the Nuisance Abatement Local
Law, St. Armand looks like the only one that actually has one and our Nuisance
Abatement Local Law boils down to one simple premise, if you are doing
something on your property that makes it so their neighbor cannot peacefully
enjoy their own property then you need to stop doing whatever you’re doing and
I hate to say this out loud but 9 times out of 10 for me it’s roosters. But
that Nuisance Abatement Law works, you know and I call folks up and say, hey, your
rooster is bothering your neighbor, they have asked you 10 times, if you don’t
take care of your rooster and I do have a farm out of town that takes roosters
and has on many occasions and that actually works for me and it’s on our
website and I think Dan actually drew it up in 2014, I believe it was, but it’s
a good local law and it does help. So, Clayton send it to the next town over,
and you know code violate, code violate, code violate. It’s there, we have it.
BARBER: Another on the Unsafe Building
Law, you know you put up with it for so many years and you come, obviously to
the County and say, okay then I am going to have this property cleaned up and
then you’re adding the expense, which I know Mike you don’t want too much of an
expense and then it comes up to $60,000-$70,000 and then you come to the
conclusion is the property really worth that when you get done cleaning it up
and you’ve got to make it a piece of land two-thirds of an acre or one acre,
how much is it worth? It is worth $60,000-$70,000 plus what’s owed on back
taxes and stuff?
THURSTON: It’s tough
MASCARENAS: Let me go to that, because
it keeps coming up. In terms of the County and the expense. You’re right, it
can get quite high. The annual warrant it excessive that we pay out to all the
taxing entities within Essex County to make them whole and be able to pay their
bills. The thought process behind that was you would recoup those dollars
during the resale of the property. We know that Hennepin has kind of put a
wrinkle in that. So, we’re never going to break even again, we’re also going to
lose. We mostly always lost to begin with. A couple of auctions prior to,
property values went up and we did make a little bit of money. This most recent
auction though and here is what I can tell you, I’m not sure there’s a way that
I am aware of that the County isn’t going to have to pay. So, what’s been
happening, Dan gave you the one scenario of you do the work locally, you take
on your responsibility and then the money goes on the warrant, the County makes
you whole and we’re never going to sell it for the $70,000-$80,000 that just
got pushed to the warrant because of your removal, we’re going to take a loss.
What happened in this last auction is houses that didn’t get sold, I am dealing
with it now. So, I’ve got without naming any names or any towns, we’ve had to
do clean up at one property, we just were sighted on another one. Now I haven’t
owned this property only since about November, so these were properties that
were in disarray for long periods of time and the County takes ownership and
all of a sudden communities want to do something about it, but for 30 years
they didn’t, a property in that condition since November and I am having to pay
for it anyway. The only difference is, I cant get the reimbursement because now
we’re the owner. So, if the property
would have sold for more dollars, we would have been okay, but now the County
is the owner and responsible for whatever code violations happen on that
property until sale. So, I think too, that’s what comes back from your
Committee, and where we’ve been trying really hard, all these conversations are
part of the larger conversation of who is going to share the responsibility and
who’s going to help in paying it. The Town of Jay, when we were in that
position once said, hey Mike we’ll split the cost with you and I am like, okay
done. That’s the first community that has ever offered to throw some money at
what I perceive as some of their own issues in terms of dealing with it and
that’s where your Committee kind of came in and we said well, we’ll look at everything
on a case by case basis basically because there’s not always a black and white
answer. There’s a lot of gray when it comes to housing and how did that house
get into that condition to begin with and what happened there, but I think
having that shared responsibility is the only access, short of pushing the entire
cost onto the County. Because if we take the property, I get the cost, if we
don’t take the property and you deal with it, we still get the costs. So, I’m
sure what the better way is short of communities feeling like, if they feel
like this is really an important issue to them then a shared mechanism for that
expenditure probably shouldn’t be off the table, because we already paid you
for that tax. We already made you whole on it, so then to come back and pay
even more on it seems extreme for me, but I want our County to look nice. I
want the Town I live in to be nice. I have been dealing with housing for an
awful long time. I was the County Planner. It’s a subject that never seems to
improve and we have actually come a long way in the last few years. We have
given ourselves some more tools, but there’s just tools, we need more tools and
how do we deal with this blight issue is a really big question.
MANNING: Mike, probably for the last 10
years I have sent letters to the Board giving all these options and everybody
looks at it and nothing happens. I can’t even recall what they said, but some
of them said stuff like, set up a fund
here at the County to take care of these expenses and have it shared, suggest
that each town contribute yearly, maybe $8,000 per Town, to this fund and that
fund can then be used to reimburse the County or to do projects or you can
budget, you can simply budget without any help from the Towns to do these
things. But I think I probably sent about 4-5 letters, 2-3 page letters on this,
I can hunt up now that we have this Committee which is great to kind of
reexamine these issues.
O’BRYAN: I just wanted to say a couple
of different things. First of all, I appreciate you bringing this up, let me
back up, my former life as a Justice in this County, I can tell you I had a
number of these cases over the years that came before my bench. What the Town
Attorney would do or what the Court would do is we try to get this person to
move in the right direction and explain the law to them, explain why they’re
out of compliance with the law and what it’s going to take to get in compliance
and give them time to do that and in pretty much every case we were successful
with getting that done. In that said, there’s always those few that you can’t
and you have to proceed forward with their sanctions. We, right now, are going
through some work in Ticonderoga, looking at ourselves, because I said to my
team as we started this year, the Town is dirty and if we’re going to attract
business and attract people to want to invest in our community we’re going to
have to clean up ourselves and so we’ve started that. Actually, DEC had 5
members, investigators, in one part of our town. We didn’t call them, they came
because there was another problem that fits right into wants going on with
blighted properties and they’re looking at where there are potentially been
illegal businesses running for periods of times and so they came in and we were
with them, my Code Enforcement Officer was with them last week as they went through this property out there.
So, we’re going to do some work on blighted. We have a plan for doing that across
the town in the next several months into the year. One thing that we do have
that’s not here; is we do have a Nuisance Law. We do enforce the nuisance law.
Typically, we enforce it when we had had properties where drugs are being dealt
out of and that’s the only way that we really could crack on to some of this
stuff is to apply the Nuisance Law. We have a point system, right now I think
we have one place let that is boarded up right now because of the nuisance law
and we just passed, it was a 6-month, the law was in place for that building
and it was just up for another 6-months in Ticonderoga and we had one prior to
this that we used this same law for to help us to rid ourselves of that illegal
activity and it worked and it has worked very well. It’s not easy, as Mr.
Manning was saying, but we have not any repercussion from it, that I can tell
you at this point.
HUGHES: I just want to follow up on
something that Mike said. This is not just about the aesthetics of the
communities, which is really is. I can think of 15 homes, I have pictures of
them in my office, of these blighted properties, of these unsafe structure
properties. That’s 15 families that I can have living in Essex, contributing to
the school, contributing to any number of employee opportunities and
volunteerism opportunities and we all have that. Every single Supervisor in
this room has that opportunity as well and I’ve got the smallest town in the
entire County when it comes to geographic size. So, we have a really wonderful,
yet imperfect, but really wonderful solution with the Land Bank. My purpose as
I take the Chairmanship of this Committee and begin to move it forward it’s this
year is what else can we do and what are the other options that we can enact
and that we can take advantage of that are already at our disposal that you
were speaking of Davina, that we can begin to lean on and educate ourselves on
a little bit more. So, I, absolutely hear the frustration in your voice, Mr.
Barber. I think we all have that frustration to a certain degree, and I am glad
that you are voicing that here, it is the perfect place to voice that. It’s
that frustration that I want to turn into some type of actionable item that we
can recommend, either through common cause, common conversation or just getting
more sure of ourselves when it comes to the local laws that we have or
improving those local laws to give them some more teeth.
I want to shift just for time purposes;
I want to shift into another conversation that was brought up in February when
it comes to County code enforcement. There is a conversation, I know it’s
brewing and budding a little bit about why doesn’t the County just take over
code enforcement, right? So, several of us in here have the same Code
Enforcement Officer named Colin Mangan. Colin lives in the Town of Schroon, but
he does code enforcement office work for 6 towns in this County, a third of the
towns. So, a couple of days after we last spoke in February, together, I pulled
him aside and had a conversation with him about what the pros and cons are and
I thought he did a really good job of kind of enumerating some of those and I
just wanted to go over it, because it’s not as easy, I know Mike could have
told me that in a heartbeat and Dan could have as well, it’s not as easy as we
might think. Could it potentially happen in the future? Yes, it potentially
could if we as Towns are put in-between a rock and a hard place because we are
obligated by New York State to provide code enforcement, obligated and could
Towns be sued if we don’t provide code enforcement? Absolutely, we could. So,
those are positions that none of us as Supervisors want to be in. Moving it to
the County has some pros but it has a lot of cons, too. So, I wanted to just
share this document with you and just go over it, maybe for 5 minutes just to
get it on the record. These are Colin’s ideas that he shared with me based on
his perspective from the six towns that he works with. Right now, if you
shifted it to the County, you have to think that there’s going to be a much
higher degree of accountability. In local towns the accountability might be a
little bit lower because there are neighbors that are doing that kind of code
work and it’s an interpretation, but when you bring it up to the County level,
you’re bringing it to a higher level of responsibility and accountability
because now you’re a County Officer providing code enforcement work. Some
towns, in Number Two, Zoning and Codes; some Towns have one person doing both,
shifting code enforcement to the County would force the Town to hire its own
Zoning Officer. So, you may be doing two in one with one person at a town
level, but if you take that Code Officer out of that equation, now you have to
rehire for a Zoning Officer and the may or may not want more money to perform
that singular function.
Nuisance, Garbage, Junk Laws; he stated
that local laws, if there are not already in existence, would need to be on the
books to allow the Zoning Officer to enforce so you would actually have to have
those, that language, he feels, legally for that Zoning Officer to do the work.
MANNING: Are you talking Zoning Officer
or Code?
HUGHES: I apologize, Code Officer.
And just geographic distances, so if you
need a building permit and you’re going to get the from a Code Enforcement
Officer through the County, that may require a person to drive much further
than your local town hall to get that permit which the applicant may or may not
want to do. There’s issues with benefits, vehicles, administrative costs,
municipal projects. So, we also as Town Officials can build our project, we can
build things that we need to build for the betterment of our town. I know when
I built a salt shed, I think it was a sale shed, my Code Officer was my
Building Inspector for that salt shed, I may lose out on that local control and
so he’s the General Contractor for some of those projects and now with that
shift through the County, that’s a great question and we don’t have those
answers. And of course, software and technology, if you have it at the County
level, you’re going to have the County purchase software and that investment in
technology to allow them to do the work that they need to do.
There are some pros; one less department
for the Supervisor and individual town to manage. Staffing at County levels
allow for backup, so for example you had 5-6 individuals providing full time
code services for the 18 towns, if somebody is sick or somebody is on maternity
leave or something happened and they couldn’t fulfil their responsibility, in a
town right now you might be out of luck, you would have to do a share service
agreement but at the County you would have somebody potentially to back that
person up. Warren County actually has a county model; I did not know that. So,
that’s something that Essex County could study if it ever felt like it needed
to determine the feasibility in our County. So, I just wanted to provide this
to you. There are more cons that pros at this time. I think all 18 of us have a
Code Officer to perform those functions, which is wonderful at the moment and
that will change, I am sure, in the short or long term and when it does, we’re
still stuck with a town needing to find. I do shutter at the day that the Town
of Schroon’s Code Officer retires, because Colin has made it very clear that he
wishes to work in the town in which he lives, right and good for him. I totally
get that. So, Meg, you stand to have a windfall of success with Colin when he
moves, when he decides to resign, but that is going to leave 6 of our towns in
a tough, tough spot. Will we be able to backfill that? I don’t know that
answer. Will the County have to come in? I don’t know that answer, but it is coming.
I don’t know how many years your current Code Officer has left in his career.
WOOD: It’s changing.
HUGHES: So, that is inevitability.
MENSER: Crown Point might hire Colin
full-time.
HUGHES: And take him away from the rest
of us? You’re going to be a real fast friend in this room.
MASCARENAS: I will add for those of you
that are unaware, the County used to have Codes.
HUGHES: I was unaware.
MASCARENAS: This Board voted to
dismantle the Essex County Code Department in favor of having their own
locally. I am not aware of all of the reasons why. The most I can get, I have
one woman that still remains employed here that worked for that department
before it was dismantled and she can only provide me guesses, she was young,
she was new. It was 35 years ago and there’s not a lot of record as to what the
office did, what their reasoning was for getting rid of that department and
taking the responsibility. I am guessing a lot of it is the cons that are
listed here, probably the local control and those types of things. So, I will
continue to look for information on that because it was before me and I came in
1999. So, I want to say it was in the late 80’s.
MANNING: I want to say it was when I was
here.
MASCARENAS: I’ve been here longer than
you. So, we have more to come on that.
HUGHES: Awesome, moving on to Section
Three; we’re not going to go through each one of these except for one topic.
But I want to remind you, if you see something on here that really jazzes you
and you want to get involved in trying to find a solution, these are just
topics that I have thought of and I have put down based on conversations we
have. The Land Bank started because of a presentation and a couple of us where
like, we want to know more and so a couple of us got involved and we did all
the research and we started getting the experts in and then it was a matter of
convincing our colleagues and demonstrating that there was feasibility and then
that’s how that happened. It started with a spark from an outside organization
and then it grew and grew and grew and grew. So, if there is something that you
see here, don’t expect me to take charge of that. I am not going to do that,
please don’t wait for me. I just want to organization the conversation. If you
want help, I will absolutely support you in that process. But if you see
something on here, that’s like I want to know more about that because it’s
important for my town or you think it could morph into something at the County
level, please let me know, let someone else know in this room and let’s start
going for it. Let me know and I am fully willing and able to support you in
that leadership process. So, take charge of something if you think that’s there
something in here that you really, really want to dive into and please don’t
wait. The crisis of housing is too important to just sit back. I know we’re all
busy but if you find that you have an extra couple of minutes in a month or a
day, please dive in and let me know and we will start making that more of a
priority and we’ll work with our County leaders to make sure that they’re aware
so that we can get their perspectives, historically, so we’re on the right
path.
I did provide you with this document
right here, which is brand new to the County, from the Lake Champlain/Lake
George Regional Planning Board. It is that Blighted Property Inventory for the
County, from a countywide perspective. Beth and crew did a really wonderful job
of providing information, some maps and also on the second to last page, some
recommendations on what they feel what might be worthwhile for the County to
endeavor into. So, instead of us trying to reinvent the wheel, again, if you
have an idea of something that you want to tackle in Section Three, let’s go
for it but also Beth and her team from the professional standpoint, they’ve
created some ideas that may or may not work in Essex County. Don’t really know,
right, don’t really know, but if there’s something that you see in here that
you think that this Task Force should be tackling, let’s get on that let that
become the focus. Those things, may not just a singular focus but let those
things become the focus of this Task Force, so we can potentially have a
product at the end of this year or the end of next year that we can bring to
the Board of Supervisors for conversation and consideration or maybe it’s just
taking this document that I have provided with the noes and turning some of
those noes into yeses and so dates, possibly and again I will reiterate, if you
think I am wrong on some of this, please tell me the dates so that I can add
that to here so that I can make that a more perfect document.
In your packet, also, there are just
some good news things that I provided from the press. The Town of Moriah
received a Pro-Housing Community Grant and again, from the SUN, Marist Poll
showing that housing is still the number one issue for New Yorkers and I have
provided some of the date related to that. I have not digested all of that, but
I just wanted to provide it to you in case that floats your boat. Those kinds
of data numbers, we are on the right track, I am thrilled that we have a full
house today. I really appreciate everybody being here. I don’t necessarily have
anything more for this conversation. One the back of the agenda, just some
ongoing efforts that are taking place throughout the County that I just want to
make sure that we’re staying on top of and our next meeting will be after Ways
and Means, unless there is anybody else here who want to speak to any of the
topics that we talked about today?
FOLLOS: I just want to clarify, so the
blighted property, the fine, that’s assessed by the Town Board not the Town
Judge, am I understanding that correctly?
TANSEY: I think the way you design the
law you can make either way. You can have the criminal component and the other
is going to civil component treated differently, but either way there needs to
be a procedure put in place. It needs to be clear by the Local Law, and both
sides need a clear opportunity to present their sides.
FOLLOS: Thank you.
TANSEY: The Town Board is the one that’s
going to be able to put it on the taxes. The criminal court is just on the
person.
REUSSER: Bill, is it in your agenda to,
you mentioned earlier about taking different blighted laws throughout the State
and you know, we pick and chose what would work best for our particular
communities, is that something that you’re actually doing? Or you’re just
suggesting that we have our own town attorneys, do it?
TANSEY: I still use future verb tense, I
can bring can put something together and bring it in, yes. Kind of coalesce some
ideas that I see under blighted properties and bring it in, at least provoke a
discussion of certain points or questions to add to that, yes.
REUSSER: I would appreciate that and
disseminate it to all.
HUGHES: From my perspective and I missed
because I was having a sidebar, I am 1000% behind dealing with blighted
properties and trying to do what we can to remediate blighted properties and
get our neighborhoods improved and get families into those remediated
properties in an affordable way. I don’t know what that looks like, I know the
Land Bank is doing that. I want to find other ways to do it so we’re not solely
relying on that, but blighted property is my up here raison d’etre for being up
here right now. I just really want to see opportunities to improve that
throughout the County and hopefully throughout the North Country.
BARBER: So, my question would be and in
my own opinion, I would think that we would all want to be on the same page as
far fines. But when you talk about the Town Board actually being able to put in
on the taxes because if you go to the court and correct me if I’m wrong, if you
go to the court system and it’s just the person is up for the fine but again,
we have so many fines now that aren’t paid and there’s usually nothing done
about and I am talking mostly that I know of, of traffic fines that aren’t paid.
So, would it be in the next interest for all of us to put it to the Town Board
so we’re able to put it on the taxes. So, they either pay the taxes or they
lose the property?
TANSEY: I don’t think, it’s impossible
to say yes or no, because each circumstance is going to be different but if
you’re going to impose it on the individual as a criminal fine, maybe you only
have a tenant, maybe it’s a non-property owner, then going to a criminal court
and imposing a fine is the better way of doing it. Once you impose the fine,
you got to go through a process of setting up a judgement to collect in the
future, collect on their property in the future. So, it’s really a two-step
process. If you keep it at the Town Board level, now you just got to make sure
that you a hearing, town boards are right for appeal, they’re right for not
following procedure, so that has to be set in place, but it’s the Town Board
that is going to put that financial burden on the tax bill, yes and then that
comes back to the very beginning of the discussion or the discussion that we
had at the very beginning of the
meeting, is who is going to absorb that tax burden? Is it going to be the
taxpayers? Is it going to the Town? Or is it going to be the County? Somebody
has to pay for it, that money doesn’t come out of nowhere.
MANNING: On an unsafe building, I have
found, I am the Town Attorney for the Town of Jay, and we have probably 7-8 or
my tenure, I think it’s a great vehicle. The only problem is, is who’s going to
pay for the demolition and now that we have Nicole’s team that are doing great
work there, if you can get them to agree with you, like they did in Jay with
the last one, that’s an excellent way to teardown an unsafe building, as long
as it’s unsafe. That’s a $64,000 question, too.
And as Bill said, I think in any Local
Law, you can put a civil component, which is a registration fee, that I think
you’re talking about, where they have to register as a blighted property and if
they don’t do anything, then you take the next step and it gets placed on that
taxes. That’s one aspect, the other aspect is a criminal or civil fee, either
one, at the Town Justice level, which as you say, never gets paid. There’s a
lot to it.
HUGHES: I lovely conversation, this is
awesome, super great. Anybody else wishes to speak?
MORSE: I just have an update, when I
look over your list on the agenda, the Community Services Board has increased
their desire to figure out how we can better support those individuals that the
Community Services Board serves. People with mental health issues, people with
intellectual developmental disabilities and people that have substance use
disorders. A lot of times those individuals also have poverty as part of their,
of the mix. So, as we watch the numbers of homeless people that are seeking
support for the Department of Social Services go up and a few of you call me
and say, this person is street homeless in my community, how can you help me? I
think they have a mental health issue and sometimes you get frustrated with my
answer. But clearly, we need more housing for individuals that are unhoused or
lack housing. So, the Community Services Board, as the need is increasing,
their awareness and their desire to come together and figure out the solution
is increasing, which is great. So, we are going to be hosting, not a forum, not
a big meeting, but maybe a dozen to a dozen and half people that have, you know
that housing and the population is near and dear to their hearts. So, I am
asking you, I’ve got a handful of people that are interested, but I am asking
you guys if there’s like a church, pastor, church in your towns that are coming
to you and saying, like these people are always at my door looking for money
and they don’t have anywhere to do, there’s no place for them to go, would love
to have somebody in the clergy world at our table because I think that a lot of
the people that I am talking about tend to go to their local church and ask for
support and not always is the church able to support. I would love to replicate
what’s going on in the Frankin County area with their ecumenical solution to
supporting individuals that have housing needs, transitional housing needs.
HUGHES: Thank you for reminding us that
it’s not just an economical issue but there are also other challenges out there
that require housing needs.
MORSE: I appreciate you hearing that,
too.
HUGHES: Thank you, absolutely. Anybody
else have any other topics out there, today?
Thank you for the fruitful conversation,
we will keep working over the month and we will see you on May 26, after Ways
and Means. We’re adjourned, thank you.
THERE
WAS NO FURTHER BUSINESS TO COME BEFORE THIS TASK FORCE WAS ADJOURNED AT 11:57 AM.
Respectively Submitted,
Dina Garvey, Deputy Clerk
Board of Supervisors