Environmental
Health Task Force
Monday, July 6, 2026 - 11:00 am
Joe Pete Wilson - Chairman
Chairman Wilson called this task force to
order at 11:01 am with the following in attendance: Clayton Barber, Matt
Brassard, Tim Follos, Mary Lamphear, Tracie McGill, Clayton Menser, Tim Pierce,
Richard Preston, Cathy Reusser, Davina Thurston, Joe Pete Wilson, Mike
Mascarenas, and Jim Dougan.
Deputy present: Dina Garvey
WILSON: We got a lot of, a very detailed
agenda with a lot of stuff on it. I think some of can move quickly. Jim, do you
want to start off and give us the Fish Hatchery update?
DOUGAN: Sure, the Fish Hatchery; we did
put a bid out. We didn’t receive any bids. We did list out the locations and
the number of fish based upon on historically what we’ve done in the past. DEC
has semi-committed that they would stock the two ponds that are public access
all the time, because it fits within their regulations. We’re trying to get a
letter from them of exactly what they would stock, so that we can redo a bid
with less fish. In the meantime, we’re also, our Supervising Fish Hatchery
Technician has been working with some of his contacts throughout the industry
to see who’s interested in providing us some fish. What we really think
happened is those companies are used to someone calling and saying, hey bring
us 200 fish. They’re not used to looking at the fairly thick bid package and
all the state, local, federal requirements that we put out there. So, we’re
working on that and trying to find some more interest to make sure that we’re
still able to stock those facilities.
WILSON: Which are the two ponds that DEC
said they could possibly cover?
DOUGAN: Roe Pond in Moriah and Deep
Hollow, here in Elizabethtown are both public access all the time, so they
would fit their regulation. We’re also getting creative. We still do have the sticking
truck that we’ve used in the past, so if we can find some more bidders by us
utilizing that truck rather than having them making that delivery, we may do
that.
WILSON: Alright.
MASCARENAS: I do think we probably need
kind of a drop dead deadline on that, only because we’re in July and those
stockings are going to happen next spring or they’re not. Those fishing derbies
expect that they’re going to continue to operate. Another option that I think
we can look at is us utilizing the occupancy funds that we get. That is what I
would be using to buy the fish anyways for those communities listed here to
purchase their own. There may be value in doing that in terms of if they can do
that on their own. I think it’s something that we need to look at, at this
point, being that time is running out, and we didn’t just bid it once, we bid
it twice.
HUGHES: Just a quick rebuttal on that
one, wouldn’t it be the responsibility of the town to do that since they County
is getting out of this business and the towns receive their own occupancy tax
money?
MASCARENAS: You can
HUGHES: Not a popular idea (laughter).
MASCARENAS: I know, that’s going to be
up to 18 different weighted votes, right (laughter)?
HUGHES: I won’t do so well.
MASCARENAS: As we set it up today, I am
paying for it, the County, Essex County is paying for it.
HUGHES: Right
MASCARENAS: So, under that assumption we
could pivot and partner with our fish and game clubs, locally and those types
of things to put the ownest on them to be able to get those fish, get them
delivered and do what they have to do for their tournaments, locally. Because
it does only impact only 8 towns and when I say, it only impacts 8, I
understand how important it is to those communities that have these derbies.
They’re extremely important, well attended, and so we need to figure it out, I
think within the next month or so which way we’re going to go with it.
LAMPHEAR: Do we have how much it is for Newcomb;
how much we’re paying?
DOUGAN: You’re not paying anything.
LAMPHEAR: No, no, how much we would be
paying.
HUGHES: The cost.
MASCARENAS: We can get an estimate
pretty quickly.
DOUGAN: We have an estimate based off a
firm that didn’t actually give us a bid that to do all of the fish was about
$60,000, which was the amount of money that were carrying from occupancy taxes,
historically for the last decade, it was coming directly out of occupancy tax
to go to Fish Hatchery, about that same amount, so about $60,000 is what. We
used their retail rates that one firm had and what they were willing to talk to
us about but then they didn’t provide us a bid, which makes us think that they were
interested in all of our requirements.
LAMPHEAR: I would just like to know how
much, just to be able to bring that for conversation if we were paying
occupancy tax. We have some water up there so that we could do our fishing
derby.
MASCARENAS: Yeah, Mary, we can get
exactly what you get stocked and we have a number per fish based upon the age
that we could give you a pretty solid number.
DOUGAN: It’s basically on here, the
number of the fish. It’s on that top chart.
MASCARENAS: Oh, yeah, it’s right there.
HUGHES: But times how much per fish.
MASCARENAS: Yup, right. It would be a lot cheaper than you think.
BRASSARD: I mean I am fine with what you
mentioned, having it go to towns. I mean I am assuming that the County would
give that portion.
MASCARENAS: Well, I just had somebody
else say no, so you guys can fight that out.
BRASSARD: I mean I have no problem doing
the legwork and finding someone to do that and all that.
HUGHES: Right or graduating the County
out of it over the course of 3 years and the towns pick it up or something like
that. Teach a man to fish (laughter), I have heard that today.
BRASSARD: Well, the fact is, 2027 I know
that these fishing derbies, I know that some of them, I don’t know if all of
them have already happened, but you have to plan now.
HUGHES: Absolutely, I agree with you.
BRASSARD: For Moriah’s next year.
MASCARENAS: And we had that discussion
prior to you walking in. We’ve got Etown’s, I’m making the assumption that the
County’s splitting the bill right now, but as you’re well aware, my vote
doesn’t count. My weighted vote is zero, and so we’ll see how that goes.
WILSON: So, to sum up fishing derbies,
Jim to sum up fishing derbies, your current fish manager is going to try and do
some salesmanship to some of the private suppliers, and we’ll see where that
takes us?
DOUGAN: Well, actually we’re also
talking with some of the Vermont fish hatcheries who may be interested in
selling us fish, as well.
WILSON: So, there’s still a chance that
it could work out.
DOUGAN: They’re looking for revenue.
WILSON: Is there anything that I need to
do or do you need help from anyone here to keep that moving?
DOUGAN: No, I don’t think so. Perhaps it
will be a conversation with DEC, again. I am trying to get a letter from them
of exactly what they will provide those two ponds that meets their regulations.
WILSON: Great
DOUGAN: They said they can, they said
they would, but they haven’t done anything yet.
BRASSARD: Right
WILSON: That would be great, because
that’s one of the biggest.
Any other thoughts on fish hatchery or
derbies?
FOLLOS: I just want to make the comment
that you know I attended the Wilmington fishing derby this year for the first
time in about 40-years and I was surprised by the number of people from other
days who were there. So, it’s not just, I can’t speak to the other derbies, but
in Wilmington it’s not just people from Wilmington that are participating.
WILSON: That’s a good point.
MASCARENAS: It’s a very good point.
BARBER: Ken was speaking for himself on
the cost?
HUGHES: Oh, totally was speaking for
myself, absolutely.
BARBER: Okay
WILSON: Alright, then on to shared
services. We talked about it at our first meeting. Years ago, we brought his
topic up and we’ve kicked it around a bunch. I don’t really have anything
concrete at this point, but it’s something that I think we need to continue to
work on as we see how difficult it is going to be to fill retiring water and
wastewater operator shoes and how difficult it is for a town like Keene or
Essex or Chesterfield to afford a vacuum truck. I mean I think there’s a lot of
room here for us to plan out and adjust to what’s coming down the road. So, I
would appreciate it if people would keep thinking about it and as you have
ideas let’s put them on the table.
THURSTON: I love this idea. I think it
is a nice place to start; I have two ideas. The first one would be a resolution
of shared service, like we do similar to highway shared services for calling,
asphalt and sand and things like that, but the other thing that I think we
could do is set up meetings. You know, so my wastewater operator goes to Keene
and hangs out with them for 4 hours and you know just kind of make it around
each town in Essex County, have everybody do the rounds, you know so they can
learn from each other and also familiarize themselves.
WILSON: Yeah, and before Covid, Todd
Hodgson, Anna Reynolds, myself, Ticonderoga participated in this. I am trying
to remember what other towns, but we were doing some, trying to map out the
gaps in technical expertise and where towns could help each other and then
Covid kind of detailed that, because it was a lot of face to face, but I think
operators were interested in that and it also helped us start to identify needs
that a shared service program could address.
MASCARENAS: I understood it a little
different. So, it is nice to hear you guys say that. So, when you say shared
service, I think you’re, it’s something that the County is going to take over.
WILSON: Yeah, and that’s not what we’re
aiming for.
MASCARENAS: Yeah, I’ve heard both sides.
So, I have spoken to the Planning Department. I think that was their thought
around it, was that the County would develop a certain amount of
wastewater/water operators that would then be able to towns if they needed that
service and we recognize the need. I’ve meet with Todd Hodgson about a month
ago on this topic. We spoke over an hour on this topic alone and probably a few
hours on several topics because we don’t catch up much. Love the ideas, and
they definitely are great for our taxpayers, the issue becomes is what can we
expect of that one individual to do, who we count on for am awful lot of
things. Again, I rarely see Mr. Hodgson, and there’s a reason of that. So, I
think we’ve really got to be careful about capacity and what we expect one
individual to do. What we say at a meeting sometimes sounds really good and
when you go to implement it you overburden those that we rely on the most. So,
anything we do in regard to that I am asking that we just really consider time
or giving them the resources so people like Todd and step away from other
things, because he’s also been like a big player right now on our radio project
and then he’s doing the HVAC up at the jail and then he’s in your towns with
your operators. So, again, I don’t want to overburden one individual by saying,
hey, he’s got this skill set we need to capitalize on it. If that’s what we
want he would love to do it, I’m sure, but he wouldn’t come in here and tell us
no. He would say, yup, I’ll do it and then we’ll all get really frustrated
saying, why isn’t this moving quicker? Because we’re expecting a little too
much from him.
HUGHES: I would briefly state that I
think we really need to think of ways to incentive education and opportunities
to support education. I feel like when we get to shared services, we’re working
smarter not harder, but I am also thinking we’re admitting a little bit of
defeat that, yes, we know that there are not enough people to do the jobs, so
we need to share to cover the gaps that do exist. I want to take a step earlier
and we talked about this a bit, how can we incentivize young people to get into
the professions, into this water/wastewater courses at North Country and/or
elsewhere, so we can hopefully say, hey, we’re overflowing with people, we
don’t need shared services unless there is a financial incentive to do so.
Whatever we can do to incentivize education and involvement in a tenure tract
to get them the water and/or wastewater certifications that they can get, I
think is really important.
WILSON: Jim, did you want to add
anything?
BARBER: I just wanted to, the Town of
Chesterfield went in halves with the Town of AuSable, we just bought a vac
truck. They are quite expensive and I know the class to run the vac truck was
not an easy task and in fact, if I am not mistaken, just my Water
Superintendent was the only one that’s actually properly trained to run the vac
truck. It was quite a show, I didn’t stay for the whole class, but it was 2-2 ½
hour class to actually operate it and operate properly and then is, according
to the instructor, you can damage a vac truck very easily and quickly by not
operating it properly.
WILSON: Yeah, and I think you’re
bringing up what would be an example of shared services that could come out of,
I didn’t know that you guys were doing that and if we start building some
mutual aid relationships that could be a help.
BARBER: Right, and I am sure that Dave
Winters would be more than happy to go and show people how to run them. The
Town of AuSable actually runs the septic system and they’re being trained now,
the sewer operators on that side.
WILSON: Great, thanks.
MENSER: The shared service side is very
important in the training in advance is going to be very important because
Crown Point is getting ready to be enforced by DEC to replace the wastewater
treatment facility that they just finished in October and now they’re already
planning a $22 million system that we’re going to have to replace it with in
the next 7 years, and the current system requires one operator, it has to be a
Level 2, the new system requires two Level 2 operators and they just not really
exist. So, we’re in the process of trying to train somebody up but the younger
generation doesn’t want to hear it, so we’re going to have to start pushing
this kind of education on people graduating high school and from college
because that’s what it is going to take.
THURSTON: I just want to touch on that, and
I think one of the best things that we could do to interest young people to
join the technical process like wastewater and water operators is to offer
tours to juniors and seniors in high school of our local plants. Have them come
out, take a tour and perhaps learn more about it and then encourage them to
attend North Country and take those classes. So, that’s the first thing and
then the second thing is Clayton, I am really glad that you have a vac truck, I
would like to have a shared service agreement with you where the Town of St.
Armand could call on you and pay you, a day or something, if we have an
emergency and maybe offset some of your costs.
WILSON: Yeah, and that was what I was
thinking in terms of a network where we identify the assets a community or
communities can bring and have sort of templates for MOUs between communities
so that you’re not covering the costs of somebody else’s operation, but they’re
getting the help they need in a timely and more affordable way.
And one thought that comes to mind, to
the west of us, the Development Authority of the North Country, DANC, they
provide water and wastewater operators. Thay have a pool of 5 licensed operators,
and they contract with individual towns to run their facilities, and they do
the same thing with solid waste. You know, they run and that’s all, or those
are operators within that, and they charge for their services, but it works,
it’s a dependable way for small, rural counties to get the operators, like
you’re facing.
And Jim, did you have anything to add?
DOUGAN: It sounds like you’re almost
describing something like the town highway superintendents have now, like a
local association. I don’t know if that’s something that you would want to promote
an idea like that. A lot of them know each other right now, but maybe if they
had a regular meeting, a regular venue, something where they could get together
and they could talk certain topics. They train each other on things they’re
facing that somebody else will face but haven’t yet. I don’t know, but maybe
that would be worth doing. The town highway superintendents have that.
WILSON: Any last thoughts on this? But
it’s good to keep having these conversations so we do keep this moving, because
I think it’s going to become more and more important.
Then Davina has been working on a
creative idea that she wanted to introduce to people, and she’s got some
handouts.
THURSTON: Okay, thank you, Joe Pete.
Last week I had a meeting with someone pretty high up in New York State Solid
Waste Committee and I set up this meeting about a month ago and I was really
interested to hear what New York State was coming up with to us with our solid
waste issues. After this meeting I was quite disappointed because what their
plan was, was to educate people about recycling and encourage people to recycle
more and also to encourage manufacturers to use less packaging and that was all
they had. That was it, and I was very upset after this meeting to learn that
there was no real plan in the works for us. So, I stayed until 7:00 that night,
in my office, and I worked on this vision, and I believe this is possible. I
absolutely know that it will be incredibly expensive, but what this is, and I
can email everybody this, it’s quite extensive. I have shared it with Mike and
Jim and Joe Pete and Steve McNally, but it’s a strategic vision for Essex
County for a way to have us never put anymore products or trash into a landfill
every again, once this take root. I am calling it the Adirondack Resource and
Recovery and Manufacturing Center. So, basically what it is, it’s a factory
where we take and separate everything. So, glass goes to the crusher, steel
gets recycled, plastics turned into products that we can sell and that’s what
I’ve kind of given you guys just these 4 pages. So, I came up benches, picnic
tables, trash receptacles, whatever, I don’t really care what we made as long
as we’re making something and selling something and it’s a product that people
can use.
So, the idea of this is to literally use
our trash to manufacture a product. So, what doesn’t get recycled and turned
into a product either is recycled to somewhere else, Ticonderoga has a mill,
there’s a place in Plattsburgh that takes mixed paper and they make boxes, so, there’s
a use for every single item. When I
talked to Jim about this earlier today, he reminded me of his idea a few years
ago of using biowaste and compost to create like a sod facility and a
composting facility. So, this is a way for us to use our trash to make
something that we can sell, whatever doesn’t get sold or recycled, we can burn
to run the manufacturing facility, and I know everybody’s against burning, but
with new technology, new scrubbers, new scientific ways of utilizing these
materials, I think we could really be a pilot program for the entire United
States and I know it’s huge, and I know it’s big, and I know it’s expensive,
and I want it all, and I want it all for us, and we can partner with Hamilton
County, Franklin County, Clinton County, St. Lawrence County, Warren County. We
could do something amazing for everyone in our area, and what I am really
looking for from all of you is to buy into this vision, and you know agree that
we should stop doing what we’re doing because it doesn’t make sense. It doesn’t
make sense to keep burying trash. Within 3-5 years, Franklin County is going to
say, I am sorry, we don’t have any place for your trash anymore. What are we
going to do then? With this idea we don’t even have to ask that question ever again.
We’re going to want trash from Clinton County and Hamilton County and St.
Lawrence County, bring us your trash. Let us turn it into something that we can
sell, something that everyone needs.
WILSON: Questions for Davina?
REUSSER: I would just like to compliment
her on her efforts. Jim and I have had discussions, it started over the piece
of paper that tells people, you know where to put what particular product and I
also come back to personal responsibly. How do we get people not to bring as
much plastic home? How do we kill that service that we’re given when we go to
get less, and we’re given a plastic container? How do we stop that? Because
personal responsibly is a big part of this, on the user side. So, we could
resolve our own, start to resolve, start to educate. So, I like the endeavor,
it feels like a hell of a lift.
THURSTON: Big lift.
REUSSER: But Essex County’s known for
being a driving force, we have had a lot of great ideas. We’re small, we’re
resourceful, we’re mighty, we seem to get stuff done, so I hope this grows some
arms, and legs, and I support the idea.
WILSON: And as a thought we have taken a
concrete step. The glass crusher was a model for this, eliminating trucking,
making a usable final product that stays local. It’s replacing us buying
gravel, you know, we’ve got a model, we’ve done a step of this, and I think
building on that, and exploring how we can do it, is a worthwhile thing.
MENSER: Myself and Matt, attending the
briefing at Sylvamo, now, with a company called Bright Sands, that is new to
the area that is going to be making fertilizer out of waste products and that
would be a good place for anything that is, I will say, biodegradable or that.
We would dispose of that stuff through them and determine what stuff could be
good for the County.
THURSTON: Absolutely.
MENSER: So, I think that would be a good
place to find out, okay, how can we partner with them. Do our strategy for
solid waste and get rid of the other stuff because they’re going to want it.
THURSTON: Right, absolutely, and along
those lines, there are a lot of different partnerships that we can form for
different products. You know, the steel, the metal, there’s a scrap metal place
in Cadyville that I can think of. I don’t know where they send their stuff.
Rubber, there’s a company near the border in Canada and they take tires and
they turn it into mulch for like playgrounds and things like that. So, you
know, this is an octopus with many, many tentacles, and we can partner
different products with different companies all around our area.
LAMPHEAR: I want to thank you for all
that you have done. I am just looking at some of the products, going, our
municipalities would be buying these, and you know when you put down here, last
in the Adirondack weather. So, my community, we would be purchasing, so it’s like
a double win, so thank you.
HUGHES: Davina, I like a lot of this, I
really do, I applaud your efforts to think outside the box, I think that’s
where big ideas tend to happen. I want understand your vision a little bit
better. How do you, what do you do with things like, what do you think we would
be doing with things like greasy pizza boxes?
THURSTON: Well, out factory needs
fodder. Our factory needs things to burn for energy to produce.
HUGHES: So, part of your vision is to
create a factory that would incinerate?
THURSTON: Yes
HUGHES: Okay
THURSTON: Yes, yes, yes. So, instead of
having a mountain of trash, because there is certainly a lot of waste, like
that pizza box that you can’t recycle them.
HUGHES: Right, I am trying to think of
the non-recyclable things that I throw away.
THURSTON: Sure
HUGHES: Like the yogurt containers.
THURSTON: Right, but maybe that yogurt
container is a key component in the plastics, I’m not a scientist.
HUGHES: Of course
THURSTON: So, I don’t know exactly how
this would work, but certainly I think a huge part of this is the Adirondack
brand, right? So, people, our people could get really excited about the fact
that, hey, we don’t have to separate anything anymore, they want everything
plastic. Every plastic goes in the bin, and it gets melted down and turn into
whatever. I think that is huge, you know, and I think I will email the entire
report to everyone. I had to scan it in two sections because it was too big for
my scanner. I don’t have all the answers.
HUGHES: That’s okay
THURSTON: But I really, I have the
vision of what it could be, and I do think we could get a lot of support
financially for this and I think, you know, Essex County can be a leader, and
we can lead the way for the entire United States to stop burying trash.
HUGHES: I think the good news is that
this model is already working, what you presented here.
THURSTON: Yes
HUGHES: I would love to know more about
your vision for the environmental side when it comes to the incineration, when
it comes to that, you used the word factory, and I also hesitate to use the
word factory, but what does that look like? What does that feel like?
THURSTON: Sure
HUGHES: I would be interested in
learning more about that.
THURSTON: Absolutely
HUGHES: Because that’s a huge component
for me.
THURSTON: Yes, and the scientific part
of it with new smokestacks, and they different scrubbers. So, I have been
reading a lot, and of course it’s very technical, but you can clean that air
emission so that it’s not toxic, and I mentioned that many times in this
report, that we would never want to do anything that would be detrimental to
the environment, you know the complete opposite of that is true. So, I just
wanted to give you the end, this is exciting to me. I think I would love to see
everyone in the United States be able to buy one of these benches or picnic
tables from Essex County waste. But certainly, I think a lot of your questions
might be answered in my report that I will email to everyone. Absolutely, I
don’t have all the answers.
HUGHES: That’s okay
THURSTON: But I do think we can get
there if we have the will. That’s the what I want from you guys, I want the
will. I have it.
REUSSER: Is Mr. Mascarenas…
THURSTON: He’s all in.
REUSSER: And Mr. Dougan, managing this?
THURSTON: Well, I don’t know if they’re
managing it, yet. I don’t know if they signed on all the way.
MASCARENAS: I’ve read it, and I think
the report is a very good start in terms of what your vision is. I’ve worked
with you an awful long time, so I absolutely understand when you get excited
about something, you’re going after it, and there’s nothing going to stop you.
There’s a lot of things to consider. I
think for me the idea is phenomenal. My opinion of not allowing the State to
walk away from their responsibility still exists, and while I am willing to do
whatever legwork to do to make that happen, I think the responsibility of trash
being placed on 36,000 people is still wrong when we’re promoted by State
agencies to come visit and develop all that trash. So, I think when we can come
up with an argument that will require the State to step in and pay their fair
share that will get somewhere.
The glass crusher is absolutely a really
good example of that. We don’t celebrate those things enough when we come up
with solutions. That was a big issue. I think there’s a lot more that we could
do rather quickly that doesn’t take years, and requires us to build a factory
right away, but I think with the tire issue is an issue in every town. I hear
it from all of you. Food, there is a lot of weight that goes into the trash in
terms of food. I do think there’s better ways to deal with that. Now, on the
flip side, we’ve got to realize that when we remove that weight from the trash
that we’re probably increasing tax dollars to individuals, because we’ve got a
system based on weight. So, replacing that system in its entirety by removing a
large component from the trash is going to take some thought, without again,
placing the ownest to pay on 36,000 people who are going to make up for it on
their property tax by removing a product from those things.
So, yeah, there’s lots of things to
consider. I am absolutely happy to go through this report and work with Davina
on further vetting out some short term goals and long term goals and how we get
there on a plan of action of what we need to do to get to that vision where we
have those awesome products at the end.
THURSTON: My vision, also, just so you
know relies heavily on grant funds from New York State, so help us help you is
what I want to say to them, and so I think we could really get support for this
if we can work out all the nuts and bolts of it.
WILSON: Davina, thank you for the
energy, and the vision, but what I think you just said ties into what Jim wants
to talk about with the solid waste in general, which is let’s pitch Essex
County as a place that the State can team up with to come up with solutions and
learn and have pilot programs. Whether it’s road salt reduction or you know,
solid waste, food waste, but let’s continue to think of ways that we can be a
valuable partner that the State wants to fund and work with our projects, and I
think we come out much better off with that.
BARBER: I just want to make, Davina,
thank you for all of your work, and I am totally in support of it, and looking
at this, I also question the compact station. In fact, I am bringing it up at
this meeting, because we’re not being sustainable at the cost that we’re at,
and of course, me being a Supervisor, the last thing I want to do is raise the
price of something along with everything else. I guess our big question is,
we’re sitting here, wondering, okay, what do we do with all the plastic stuff
because I only collect #2 plastic and I’ve always wondered, and I know someone
of you are allowed to take clear plastic because you have the containers to do
it, which I do not, but I always wonder about the materials, the #5 plastic,
all the other numbers that are not being recycled on. We’re bringing them, and
you know you’re garbage cans, I purchase those, and they’re quite expensive,
and I purchase them for the durability of them because other trash cans that
I’ve had at my parks, and stuff are being destroyed, and these are much heavy
duty material and they last a lot longer, so I am spending the extra money, so
I guess that’s what we’re all wondering. What do we do with all these plastics
and to do the research to find out where we can dispose of the #5 plastics and
etc., along with the metal. I do have Moore’s Recycling for metal in my town.
Which if you go by there is a whole field of metal recycling that they do
there, very good work.
WILSON: Alright, so we’re going to talk
about our progress with the State on our solid waste management plan.
DOUGAN: Exactly what Davina’s offering
up is really what the State wants out of us, and so the first part, talking
about solid waste is going to be our response to DEC on our local solid waste
management plan that we did submit. They gave us back 25 comments that were
really one size fits all look at State regulations and telling us that we
don’t, our plan didn’t meet their regulations, but they would forget that they
took landfills away from us 20-25 years ago. So, the last time we had
Environmental Health Committee we said we were going draft a letter to go back
to them. We didn’t have a meeting in June, so I have a letter drafted. I am
just going to read it to you and make sure everyone’s kind of okay with that. I
probably should have printed copies to everyone, but. We’re sending this to the
Director of the Solid Division of DEC.
Thank you for your department’s
continued review of the Essex County Local Solid Waste Management Plan. As the
County, we have reviewed the comments provided, two general themes have emerged
that we believe warrant further discussion. First; most of the comments appear
to apply in a more generalized or statewide perspective, rather than the
localized approach contemplated under the requirement 4 of the local solid
waste management plan. Essex County’s system operates under a unique
combination of circumstances, including Adirondack Park land use restraints,
mandatory long distance waste export, low population density, and significant
seasonal population fluctuations. We believe these factors are critical to
evaluating the feasibility and appropriateness of various programmatic
expectations.
Second; the County believes that
additional discussion would be beneficial regarding the practical limitations
that rural geography and socioeconomic conditions place on participation,
infrastructure viability, and programming limitations. Many of the County’s
planning decisions were not based only on environmental goals, but also on
realistic participation and expectations, fiscal sustainability and long term
operational feasibility. The department has indicated, both with its comments
and through public statement by Commissioner Amanda Lefton, that Essex County
should pursue alternative solutions. The County welcomes that discussion and
looks forward to meeting with department staff to better understand what cost
effective, locally focused alternatives that the department believes are
achievable within Essex County’s unique circumstances. This discussion should
also include recognition that certain state land use and policy decisions have
eliminated or significantly limited options that may be available to other
planning units throughout New York State.
Given these concerns; Essex County
appreciates the department’s recent offer to meet with County staff to discuss
the plan and associated comments and would welcome that opportunity. We believe
a direct discussion would be beneficial to ensure the County’s plan is
evaluated within the proper local context and help identify practical and
achievable paths forward that align with both State objectives and local realities.
Please let us know your availability in
the coming weeks. Thank you for your continued consideration.
So, Richard Clarkson is the Director of
Solid Waste Management Division, somebody that Mike talked with who actually
did get that first $300,000 moving forward and he actually, in a phone conversation
with me, offered to come meet with us. He did that just before sending these
comments. I think he, sending the comments I think he realized that we were
probably put our foot down and say, we didn’t really care for those comments.
So, I just want to make sure that you’re all okay with sending a letter like
that out and actually asking to have that meeting with them, here, with them
face to face.
WILSON: Any objections?
HUGHES: It’s not an objection. I like
the letter a lot, I might consider striking that second paragraph, about
socioeconomic conditions, because it just sounds like were crying poor and I
don’t know if that’s necessarily anything that’s going to move the ball
forward. I think we have to use their own decisions, I won’t say against them.
But they put us in this position. The fact that we have socioeconomic
conditions, well, every county has got socioeconomic conditions. So, I like the
tone and tenor of the vast majority, respectfully, of that entire letter, I
think it hits the head on the nail, but I just don’t know if we need to go into
the socioeconomic aspects, because name me a county that’s not going to extol
their socioeconomic issues to try and convince the State. I think the State is
going to be like, nope, whatever. That’s
just my opinion.
MASCARENAS: Yeah, I don’t think you are
wrong, I think it depends on what you’re looking at. Maybe there’s a way to
reword it. It’s less about socioeconomic conditions but the economics of the
situation are relevant because of the 4 million visitors that come here every
year that are promoted by New York State and we’re putting on the back of
36,000. So, regardless of what those individuals earn is irrelevant, it’s the
unfairness of the burden that matters.
HUGHES: I like that angle, a lot.
MASCARENAS: Right, I think that’s
probably what we need to be able to say.
HUGHES: We think about ORDA, we think
about Lake Placid, we think about all these State associations, organizations
that are promoting, promoting, promoting it get people up in this area, right
and then they’re not supporting once they’re here and that’s what we’re talking
about. We want them to support what they’re creating and it’s not happening the
way it needs to happen.
THURSTON: Help us help you.
HUGHES: Help us help you, right? Don’t
leave us out to dry and I so, I hope you get that meeting and if it’s Mr.
Clarkson, make sure you wear your Clarkson hat when you go to that meeting,
he’s the wheel; right? But, extolling the socioeconomic status of Essex County,
I don’t think that gains us anything, but I do agree with you, sir. That it’s
the burden and the economics of the situation that is unfair to us as a County,
unfair to our taxpayers, and that they need to do better and we’re going to
work with them to do better. It’s a partnership, it’s a shared service, but
they’ve got to step into that as well. Those are just my points.
REUSSER: It’s a we thing.
WOOD: I get exactly what you’re saying,
and I do like how you’re putting it. I think we should stress that this is an
infrastructure need that is equal to electricity, water, sewer, across the
board, it’s part of that whole thing. It’s not an extra, it’s part of our
infrastructure.
WILSON: And we’re the frontline Sewards of
the Adirondack Park here and we’re open, I mean on Saturday morning up at the
Garden Parking Lot, where we don’t have trash cans, because we’re on State land
and we practice leave no trace and he’s handing me his coffee cups and saying
will you throw these away for me and that happens every time I’m up there and
you know, we’re protecting the State’s investment on the backs of our
taxpayers. So, we’ll work on rephrasing that.
DOUGAN: Just for similar to where
Clayton just was, regarding not increasing his fees, he’s cognizant of that. When
I wrote socioeconomic, that is some of what I was thinking and I was thinking
about, if he raises his fees, some of that garbage ends up on one of our back
roads. So, that’s where, but we’ll rewrite it. But they need to understand that
that’s what happens here. Our whole system is based upon tonnage. The more
tonnage we have, the more cost effective it. Start pulling the tonnage out and
the price per ton to handle it goes up and they need to be cognizant of it.
They are so oblivious to that in what their statewide CRR whatever the number
is requirements, that they’re actually pushing it to be dumped on the side of a
backroad and we’ve got a lot more backroads than some of the counties that
they’re sending the same amount and so what comes out of the letter, if you
have a meeting, is an agenda that this group, I hope helps me create. What do
we want to push? At the same time that you’ve got a nice idea, they want us to
have all those ideas, they do. I think it’s their job to come up with some of
these ideas to help us a little bit. They’re got a lot bigger experts than we
do, but their response to almost everything is, you tell us what you think you
want to do and then we’ll tell you how you do it or not. Just found a new site
that’s going to save Willsboro half a million dollars, but they’re going to
come in and find wetlands that are never coming back. So, same kind of
situation.
So, we agree, we get a letter out and
maybe modify this one some.
WILSON: And see what kind of response we
get and ideally it would be a date to meet.
DOUGAN: I did get responses back from
our consultant and I will email those out to everybody. I kind of categorized
them and when I sent them out, you’ll see I color coded it like I do at budget
time. About ½ of the comments are B&L
think are easy for us to answer and don’t put us in a lot more administrative
work, but then the other half are the ones that we should really talk about.
WILSON: Any more questions for Jim about
the report.
HUGHES: Just a very quick sidebar, we
just raised our transfer station ticket prices from .14¢ and pound to .16¢ a
pound and we had no problem at all.
WOOD: That’s dirt cheap.
HUGHES: Very transparent about the
process, the reasons why, we did the whole data thing, we went back 7 years, 6
years, 8 years, something like that and not an issue at all. So, if you feel
like you’re not solvent, don’t be afraid to get yourself to solvency because it
worked for us in Essex and I am very happy with it.
WOOD: Just a quick question; does the
County have a library of photographs of backroads with TVs sticking out of the
ground?
DOUGAN: I’ve got some.
WOOD: Include a few of those and tell
them how many miles of backroads that we have. It’s just a smart aleck remark.
BARBER: We can get you those pictures,
that’s for sure.
WILSON: Meg, I am actually in the middle
of another investigation into illegal dumping. We’re really aggressive about it
in Keene.
BARBER: Yeah
WILSON: Calling DEC and rummaging
through trash and getting IDs out of it.
WOOD: We’re doing pretty well,
ourselves. But we’re .25¢ a pound and have been for a few years and you know
what? If we did, like what we’re going to do with our golf course, figure out
what it really cost to run without losing money…
HUGHES: I do have a smaller station, so
I do recognize that.
WOOD: We’re a County Transfer Station.
HUGHES: Right, yes.
MASCARENAS: Right, and the cost you
don’t see if my cost.
WOOD: Oh, yeah, right
MASCARENAS: So, I am budgeting an
additional million dollars a year in terms of the equipment and all of that.
That’s the difference, so we’re a million to the bad in terms of solvency.
THURSTON: And the recycling, you know,
we don’t charge anyone for the tonnage on the recycling.
MASCARENAS: But you guys are our client.
So, if we were to raise our fee to you, you would then you’re going to have to
turn around and raise your fee.
BARBER: Something that we did in
Chesterfield, we opened up the food compost, we went to River Valley, and I
didn’t put a charge to that, so that’s going to be my combat this time. We took
the food out of the trash, made your trash lighter, so it doesn’t cost you as
much to get rid of it, but yet we still get charged.
REUSSER: There’s a couple of things that
come out of that though, and that is it does change people’s behaviors. If it’s
costing them more, yes, you’re going to have to keep going to the dump, but
that’s why there’s game cams and the favorite dumping spots can get monitored
and you can take it that route, which gets around that and that changes the
behaviors.
WILSON: To start, Jim, do you want to
cover a couple more points here before we wrap up?
DOUGAN: They’re pretty much spelled out
there. We talked about A, we talked about B. The State, you know we did have
the $300,000. I forget where it was Mike, was it in DEC, again?
MASCARENAS: No, it was moved.
DOUGAN: Which was nice. It was moved out
of DEC, which was good.
Item D; Joe Pete, maybe you want to talk
about that.
WILSON: Yeah, so this is related to the
Adirondack Council approach. Steve, Jim, myself, about the issue of solid waste
and what it costs and the potential of a negative impact on the environment,
here in the Park and they made this funding for Essex and Hamilton counties one
of their top 5 legislative priorities this year and had their lobbyists and
their members pushing to solve like the payments and how it’s budgeted and I
think that their interest in partnering with us in trying to represent these
issues is they’re recognizing the role that the residents and local government
take in really the frontline protection of the environment here. So, they’re
looking at this as a community issue, environmental issue and I think it’s
going to be valuable for us to work with partners like that or the State with
the ideas that you have. So, I just want people to be aware that this issue is
attracting attention in ways that normally we wouldn’t have partners, but part
is because of the way we’re positioning ourselves, that we want to solve this,
we want to continue to protect the environment and so our interests in this, in
this case the Adirondack Council’s interest line up and it’s to the good of all
of us. So, I think this mindset we’re starting to use is paying some rewards.
Back to you on the last one?
DOUGAN: You’re the one that found that
book, you invited me to that.
WILSON: Okay, so did you distribute it
yet, I can’t remember?
DOUGAN: We sent an email.
WILSON: So that book from when we were
all small children, points out that these, it was commissioned by the first
Governor Cuomo to study the issues in the Adirondack Park and solid waste was
right there and I think reading that helped shaped the idea that Jim and I have
been kicking around of you know, the responsibility, the State bares some responsibility
for supporting the work we do, since the State owns a good chuck of our towns,
our county and we’re doing this work. So, look through that, there are
interesting things that echo really clearly. It talks about housing, solid
waste, demographics, all the things we’re…
DOUGAN: How about roads? It talks about
additional funding just for our roads. I mean there are a lot of things that we
talked about today that they identify in a report that they, the Governor
commissioned, that we talked about today, that they identified here in the
Adirondack Park, that the State of New York needs to fund. To me it’s a
recognition that they put certain land use controls in play that don’t give us
the opportunity to compete with additional residents to share the burden, they
identified that. They identified that, they, the State needs to fund some of
that, if there’s going to continue to have this Adirondack experiment that we
all are living. They can’t expect us to pay all of it. That’s some of the
things that I read out of this book. And they talked about housing, way back
then. So, I just think from a legislative approach in dealing with them that
you may want to remind them, you said it yourself, 36 years and nothing’s
really changed.
WILSON: So, Matt Brassard and I, in AATV
have been talking a little bit about AATV’s legislative agenda and one thing
that I would like us to draft in anticipation of next year is a legislative
agenda that has some items from this committee and having our own floating up
from our committees, having a legislative agenda with some real concrete asks
and I think we’re moving towards some of that and Matt and I are going to talk
again to start trying to formulate what those might be and how we might use a
legislative agenda to affect change at a State level to help us with all this
stuff. So, in closing I’ll saying that’s why having this discussion, reading
that book, coming up with these ideas, is important because I think we need to
channel this work and thinking into more time down in Albany and with some real
concrete, well-though out asks that integrate with the issues we’re trying to
address. So, keep that in mind and we’re going to get together and sort of
start kicking some of that around and we’ll keep bringing it back to this committee.
I am going to encourage other committees to develop some legislative agenda
items, as well.
So, and the last thing I want to say is,
thank you for everyone who stayed for this very non-glamourous committee. We’re
not making any headlines here, but this is really important stuff, and it
affects our, you know, every town’s budget, the County’s budget, our residents,
our visitors, our economy, all of that. So, it’s not glamourous, but I
appreciate such a turnout and so much participation. Thank you very much and
we’ll adjourn at noon.
AS
THERE WAS NO FURTHER BUSINESS TO COME BEFORE THIS ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH TASK
FORCE, IT WAS ADJOURNED AT 12:00 PM
Respectively Submitted,
Dina Garvey, Deputy Clerk
Board of Supervisors